All film guides

Three first-contact films for three different moods

Start with Arrival, Contact, or Close Encounters depending on whether you want a puzzle, a debate, or a sense of wonder.

Arrival (2016) for a quiet puzzle

Arrival gets its tension from the work of translation. Linguist Louise Banks keeps returning to the same basic question: how do you know that the thing you think you heard is the thing the other speaker meant? The effort to agree on a single word gives the film more suspense than a countdown would.

Pick this if you like a film that rewards attention to its opening scenes. The pacing is patient, and the sound design makes the encounters feel strangely intimate. Leave time after the credits to compare what each person thought the film was doing with its opening images.

View film details

Contact (1997) for a debate about proof

Contact spends as much energy on what humans do with a signal as it does on the signal itself. Governments, scientists, and religious leaders disagree over who gets to speak and what should count as evidence. The exchanges work because Ellie Arroway has to live with the consequences of those decisions.

Choose it for a group that likes talking after a movie. Ask each person what evidence would convince them, then compare the answers. The film becomes an especially good companion to Arrival if you watch it second and notice how each story treats uncertainty.

View film details

Close Encounters of the Third Kind (1977) for wonder

Spielberg builds curiosity from ordinary things that suddenly feel out of place. Lights, household objects, and a sequence of notes gradually acquire meaning. The film puts the audience in the position of listening and looking before it can explain what is happening.

Choose this for the most sensory evening of the three. Give the speakers enough room to carry the music, and watch how the characters respond to the notes before deciding what the scene is asking you to feel. Its sense of wonder makes a strong finish to a longer first-contact double bill.

View film details